A Trip To India
By Jamer Chamberlain, M.D.
The Tsunami of last December changed
us all. The images of devastation and
human suffering found their
way into our living rooms and our hearts and the generous outpouring
of support which followed was a testament to the character of our
people. As I watched the story unfold I was especially affected by
images of India. As a young man I had traveled there to work
as a volunteer in a Jesuit leprosy relief program. My skills were
limited then and I promised myself that I would go back someday as
a physician when I had more to offer. It seemed like the time had
come. My Jesuit friends put me in contact with a Father AJX Bosco,
an Indian Jesuit who was organizing relief efforts, and I sent him
an email offering my services. The response was brief: "Yes, please come, fly to Hyderabad." With this
uncertainty, an expired passport, a wife and three daughters, a busy
practice, and a house under construction the idea of actually going
seemed a bit crazy. But sometimes things seem to fall into place.
With the support of my family, friends and colleagues I found myself
a short while later on a plane to India.
Father Bosco had been in contact with the Catholic Health Association
of India (CHAI) who had joined forces with the Sister Doctors Forum
of India (SDFI) to do Tsunami relief work in the southeastern coastal
area of Tamil Nadu state. I was invited to join their team and after
a short rest in Hyderabad I was on my way to the coast. CHAI and
SDFI had been working in the area since the day after the Tsunami.
Initially they had assisted with acute trauma care, mass tetanus
immunizations, securing a clean supply of clean water and emergency
shelter, and the grizzly work of cleaning up and burying the thousands
of bodies. As more people arrived they were organized into mobile
teams and sent out to the villages to set up medical clinics and
attend to the social and psychological needs of the affected people.
When I arrived a couple of weeks after the tsunami I joined one of
the teams and the next day went to work.
We were based in a village called Vaillankani
in the Nagapattinum area, which was hardest hit by the Tsunami. Vaillankani
is the site of a famous Catholic Cathedral built on the site where
the Virgin Mary is believed to have twice appeared to the local villagers
some 500 years ago. The Cathedral was miraculously spared but at
least a thousand pilgrims died on the beach just outside it when
the Tsunami came. Our group took up residence in a retreat house
next to the Cathedral. Most of the coastal inhabitants had lived
in simple fishing villages, in huts made of brick and mud. They made
their living from the sea, using anything from large ocean going
vessels to simple dug out canoes. Life was simple but they seemed
content. They had plenty of fish, they grew a little rice and some
vegetables, and they used their goats and cows for milk and sometimes
meat. They had family and real community and most people lived out
their lives just as their ancestors had. In some places the modern
world had arrived, with electricity, running water, motorcycles,
cars, even cell phones; while in others it was as if time had stood
still for centuries.
When the tsunami came all of this was taken away. Entire villages
were reduced to rubble. 13,000 people were dead and those who survived
were left with little hope. Almost no one had insurance, few had
bank accounts, and whatever wealth they had was in their homes, their
boats, their livestock, or their jewelry. Government agencies and
Non Government Organizations (NGO’s) were doing an admirable
job providing emergency aid. Temporary shelters, rudimentary structures
framed with sticks lashed together with rope and finished with corrugated
tin walls, were being built. Entire families would be housed in a
10 x 10, dirt floored room. Some had electricity (a single light
bulb) and a few had rudimentary propane camp stoves. Others cooked
over open fires in front of their rooms. Drinking water tanks were
brought in and in some places a community toilet (outhouse) was in
place. Food was being brought in to most villages and supplies of
all kinds had been donated but the distribution was inconsistent,
sadly affected by local politics, corruption, and greed. Some villages
got more than they needed while others got virtually nothing.
Unlike other Tsunami affected areas,
the health care infrastructure was intact. Local government hospitals
and clinics were attempting to meet the enormous needs but they were
overwhelmed. Much of the emergency medical support had left by the
time I arrived. The government was sending out some medical teams
but they had limited resources and were unlikely to make it to some
of the more remote and lower caste villages at all. Other NGO’s were offering assistance
but CHAI and SDFI had made the largest commitment, especially to
the poor and the marginalized. They are an amazing group of people!
Mostly nuns, all volunteers, they embody the Christian ideal of service
to the poor and suffering. Though we saw about 100 patients a day,
the Sisters and others attended to each person individually, with
dignity and respect, regardless of caste or creed. Unfortunately,
the Indian caste system is alive and well, condemning many, many
people to lives of the most desperate poverty. There are whole villages
of so called dalits, untouchables of the lowest caste, who live in
the most miserable of conditions. They are only able to get work
as day laborers in the worst of jobs, they are disenfranchised politically,
and they have essentially no hope for advancement. Our group stumbled
upon one such village while I was there called Poovanthoppu, commonly
known as Salt Street.
Poovanthoppu is a village of 106 families,
all dalits. The adults, both men and women, work half the year as
laborers in salt fields 7 days a week from 4 am to 7 pm for about
75 cents a day. The other half of the year there is no work and they
subsist on their goats and a few basic crops. The land is not fertile
so they can only grow a little rice and some vegetables. Only the
leader of the village has electricity (a single light bulb and a
beat up radio,) no one has running water or toilets. They live in
simple mud and brick huts which are falling apart. The only access
is via a narrow, rutted dirt road. The children are left on their
own all day and if they go to school at all they have to walk 2 km
to grade school and 5 km for secondary school. When they do go to
school they are treated like outcasts by the other children. Only
one child had shoes, a pair of western sandals someone had given
him. They are systematically kept in poverty by those around them,
condemned only by the misfortune of their birth. Though their constitution
grants them equal rights, ancient customs supersede the law. They
have essentially no representation and whenever they have tried to
bargain for better wages or working conditions they have been thrown
off the job. With no other work available they literally begin to
starve within days and are forced to go back to work. Health care
is virtually non existent. If they can find a private doctor who
will see them, they cannot afford the care. The government has free
hospitals but they are far away and no transportation is available.
Most of the children have chronic worm infestations and are anemic
and malnourished. A child of 10 may look 6 while a woman of 50 my
look 70. It is a very hard life.
Poovanthoppu is just far enough away from the sea to have escaped
the water and no lives were lost. No homes were destroyed but all
the goats were killed, their rice crops were ruined and the salt
fields where they worked were flooded. When our group arrived a couple
of weeks after the tsunami the people were literally starving. Teams
went out and attended to medical needs and some food and basic supplies
were brought in, but CHAI is a medical relief organization and did
not have the resources to do all that was necessary. They began working
with the government and a few trucks were sent out but most of the
materials were being diverted by surrounding villages. It became
apparent that a comprehensive rescue plan was necessary to save these
people from this desperate situation. On my visit to this village
I was overwhelmed to see such profound poverty and suffering. I am
haunted by the words of one of the village leaders as he talked of
their plight: "I wish the tsunami would come again and take
us all because we have nothing to live for." I told my wife,
Lisa this story that night and she immediately said we should adopt
this village. I approached CHAI with this idea, they were very receptive
and are prepared to stay on and do the work in Poovanthoppu now.
They know its not enough simply to give money so they are prepared
stay on for as long as is necessary to rebuild this village and give
these people some hope for a better life. All we would need to do
is come up with the cash.
These people are truly the poorest of the poor. They will not be
receiving any aid from the government or other charitable organizations
because they were not directly affected by the tsunami. They are
in need of basic necessities like housing, a sustainable source of
clean drinking water and an adequate supply of food. They need access
to decent, affordable health care, good sanitation and better educational
opportunities for their children. They will of course continue to
suffer the shame and injustice which is the birthright of the dalit
and it is unlikely we can change that. It is also unlikely we can
impact on their working conditions or their wages. But we can help.
On one trip to the mall we may spend more than the annual salary
of these people.
CHAI is a solid organization with the right set of values and a strong
commitment to these people. They are well organized, frugal and practical
and they know how to work within the Indian system to get things
done. Stretched thin by the tsunami and other activities
all over
India, they simply lack the financial resources to undertake this
project at this time.
Though I'd been to India before, my
memory was dim. I had lost the sense of what real poverty is, what
real suffering is. We all know how fortunate we are to live as
we do, to have what we have, and our hearts are all heavy when
we see the terrible images of starving children, of hopeless lives,
of despair. All of you, like me, witnessed the carnage of the tsunami
and were deeply moved. All of you searched your hearts and souls
for some way to help, and you did help. The stories of generosity
and the outpouring of compassion and love were as moving as the
stories of death and destruction. I was one of the lucky ones who
got to actually go to Asia to help, but I carried with me the compassion
and caring of all of you. Indeed I would never have gone had it
not been for the incredible support of my loving wife and daughters
and the generous financial support of my company, Maryland Primary
Care Physicians. I felt that I was an emissary of sorts, from our
little part of the
world to theirs, and the people there
expressed
their gratitude for that to you.
So when I returned from India and reentered life I kept asking myself: "What
now?" I had proposed the idea of adopting Poovanthoppu as a
neighborhood thing and many of my friends were enthusiastic and offered
to help, but I was muddled. People had already given to the tsunami
relief effort, the neighborhood had done a big fund raiser while
I was gone, and the price tag on this seemed beyond our scope. By
then the tsunami wasn't really even much in the news anymore. But
what we were talking about here was really beyond the tsunami. It
was more definite, more concrete, more personal, and it went to the
core of our shared values of compassion and service to others in
need. A natural disaster is one thing; horrendous, dramatic, heart
wrenching, but temporary. The plight of this village is like that
of a thousand villages the world over. Its chronic, unromantic, and
a little more disturbing in the end because its man made. Its like
a little Sudan, or Haiti, not much in the news anymore, kind of embarrassing,
apt to be brushed under the collective carpet. So what we're talking
about is trying to make a small dent in this biggest of human problems.
When people asked me what motivated me to go to India I said it was
just a matter of saying yes to what's in front of you, then working
out the details later. This village has been put in front of us and
it doesn't look like anyone else is going to help them. Let's say
yes to them.
Jamer Chamberlain, M.D.
March, 2005
|